Drowning in Swimming Pools: Legal Risks, Safety Norms, and Your Remedies

Drowning in Swimming Pools: Legal Risks, Safety Norms, and Your Remedies

Drowning in Swimming Pools: Legal Risks, Safety Norms, and Your Remedies

Introduction

As an experienced attorney specializing in catastrophic injuries and wrongful death claims, I have witnessed the tragic consequences when lifeless pool gates, faulty drains, or negligent maintenance lead to drowning or near-drowning. This post addresses common questions about drowning hazards, the relevant laws, and how affected families can seek justice.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Why is drowning such a critical legal and safety issue?

Answer:

  • Drowning is unfortunately one of the leading causes of death among children nationwide and remains a top threat in states like Florida.
  • Many of these tragedies result from defective pool infrastructure: mislatching or broken gates/fences, unsafe pool drains, or negligent maintenance.
  • As attorneys, we see these as preventable deaths or injuries—cases where legal accountability must follow to protect victims and deter future harm.Ā  This is especially true with our most vulnerable – the children and autistic children. 

2. What legal duties do owners or operators of pools owe to the public or residents?

Answer:

  • Owners (private, commercial, or multi-unit complexes) owe a nondelegable duty to maintain safe conditions around their pools, especially where children are foreseeable entrants.
  • This includes ensuring gates latch properly, fences comply with code, drains meet safety standards, periodic inspections, and prompt repairs.
  • A failure in any of these may constitute negligence or negligence per se (if code violations are involved). 

3. What is the Virginia Graeme Baker Pool & Spa Safety Act (VGBA), and how does it affect liability?

Answer:

  • The VGBA was signed into law in 2007 and became enforceable on December 19, 2008.
  • The purpose is to prevent suction entrapment (when body parts become stuck to pool or spa drains). A very common cause of injury or death is a child, who is already not a strong swimmer, getting sucked into and caught on a pool drain and then not being able to get out.
  • Under VGBA, public pools must have drain covers conforming to ASME/ANSI A112.19.8-2007 (or a successor) and must adopt additional anti-entrapment systems (e.g. safety vacuum release systems, automatic shutoffs) when a pool has a single main drain other than an ā€œunblockableā€ drain.
  • Although VGBA is federal law, it supplements (does not replace) state and local building codes. Pools or spas that fail to comply may increase liability exposure.  

4. Can you give examples of major verdicts in drowning or near-drowning cases?

Answer:

  • In Hinton v. 2331 Adams Street Corp., a Broward County jury awarded $100 million to a toddler severely brain-injured after she entered a pool through a broken gate.
  • In another high-profile case, The Haggard Law Firm secured a $104 million verdict in Peterson v. Sta-Rite wherein a boy was trapped underwater by suction from a defective pump.
  • These verdicts are among the largest in Florida drowning or aquatic-suction litigation.  

5. What factors tend to make these cases successful?

Answer:

Key factors include:

  1. Foreseeability and notice — Was the pool owner or manager aware (or should have been aware) of defects?
  2. Code or standard violations — Demonstrating noncompliance with VGBA, local building codes, or ANSI standards.
  3. Causation and evidence — Expert testimony linking the defect to the drowning or injury.
  4. Damages and future needs — Life care planning, cost of round-the-clock care, loss of enjoyment of life, etc.
  5. Trial readiness — Persuasive presentation to jurors, careful preparation, and a credible legal team. 

6. What should a family do immediately after a drowning or near-drowning?

Answer:

  • Secure the scene and preserve evidence (photos, maintenance logs, gate repair records).
  • Report the incident to authorities and request inspection reports.
  • Consult with an attorney experienced in drowning cases promptly — statutes of limitation may apply.
  • Avoid inadvertent waivers: do not sign releases or allow cleanup before the scene is documented. 

7. How can improved safety standards protect future victims?

Answer:

  • Every case filed raises public awareness and pressures property owners, municipalities, and elected officials to enforce stricter codes.
  • Litigation can prompt regulatory changes at the state or national levels. For example, we actively supported passage of the VGBA while working with members of Congress (e.g., Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz).
  • By holding negligent parties accountable, courts contribute to a safer environment for children and families across jurisdictions.

Closing Thoughts

As a seasoned trial attorney, I believe that the fight for justice in drowning and near-drowning cases serves a dual purpose: compensating injured families and enforcing safety standards to prevent future tragedies.

If you or someone you love has suffered injury or loss due to pool hazards, contact an attorney with proven experience in drowning litigation. Proper legal advocacy matters—and the right counsel can be life-changing for your family.

If you have been involved in an SUV or car accident in the Tampa Bay area, call Tampa Personal Injury Attorney, Martin J. Hernandez at 813-755-9500.

On This Page:

Information On This Page